Hi guys, tossing up between a Namiki Nippon Art vs. a Nakaya Cigar, both base models in either brand as it is still a lot of money compared to other pens. This creates what I think of as a slightly artificial competition between Nakaya decapods and Namiki Chinkins, between Nakaya Dorsal Fin 2s and Namiki Urushi 50 size or Yukari Royals, but they are in each case very different pens, and even the Namiki Urushi line in Yukari Royale or Emperor 50 size is quite a different finish to the Nakaya urushi offerings with very different nib sizes. Hi guys, tossing up between a Namiki Nippon Art vs. a Nakaya Cigar, both base models in either brand as it is still a lot of money compared to other pens. Copyright © 2004-2021 The Fountain Pen Network, http://www.fountainpennetwork.com/forum/topic/343593-which-indian-fountain-pen-would-you-write-a-novel-with/?p=4179072. Nakaya. I would now either purchase from Nakaya direct (my preferred route), or from a supplier with unmolested nibs. Is it basically Pilot VS Platinum? While previously I would have advised to buy from them for peace of mind, I have recently had some experiences which would give me pause. Although the Nakaya nib is somewhat less well-suited to the Spencerian modification than the Pilot nibs indicated above, Nakaya's hand-crafted Urushi pens offer a writing experience like no other. (and I’m sorry if I’ve wandered far from the OP question). Standard International Ohto Rosetta Kaweco Squeeze OMAS Standard International Pelikan ... Namiki Parker Pelikan Pilot Platinum Rotring Sailor Scheaffer Taccia Visconti Waterman Sources. The sturdy post with the teflon washer in the converter makes fitting the converter always feel secure. Platinum Coarse Nib vs. Nakaya Extra Broad Nib. A difference between Namiki and Nakaya here would be that assuming the Nakaya criteria for penmakers involves the 3 decades experience, contrast with Namiki where some of the master craftsmen can be younger, take the Emperor Goldfish made by Seiki Chida, around 50 years old (?) I plan to take it to DC to have Mike Masuyama work on it. For me they aren't really a like for like comparison because they focus on different things. That does not make them in anyway inferior; it is a matter of differences we should know about when making decisions. Copyright © 2004-2021 The Fountain Pen Network Taccia Kaku-tate vs. Nakaya Decapod Fountain Pens Comparing the Taccia Kaku-tate Wide Stripe Aquarium fountain pen with two Nakaya Decapods (one regular, one twist) to show you the differences in the pens, Urushi, and changes over time. All of the Nakayas I have were either from Mottishaw and tuned by John or from Nakaya and tuned there. Also not sure if they're cheaper than buying direct from Nakaya, except their prices look like they've bought a few batches, some from before one of the price rises. Much of the basic maki-e is silk screened as opposed to being done by hand and the hand work is done in a studio environment rather than by a single known hand. Pilot/Namiki vs Sailor vs Platinum (FPN thread-one of many on the Japanese Big Three topic) A Field Guide to Japanese Nibs (FPN ... Talk about the princess and the pea!! Representing Pilot are nibs from the capless Decimo, Custom 92, and Namiki Sterling Turtle. I have to say that Nakaya have their fingers around me. Pen: Nakaya Naka-ai Tame-Sukashi CatInk: Iroshizuku Tsuki-yo Ink. The following are our blog on Namiki and Sailor Chinkin fountain pens. I think for Nakaya the customisation is a much bigger deal, if you want to get an ascending dragon v3 in long cigar 17mm, you really can, in whatever colour you want and with a wide range of nibs with some tuning according to your specifications. I believe Nakaya and Namiki pursue different markets. Otherwise the different screens will not register locations correctly. Truthfully, I am not the type of collector that loves to have one design with a myriad different color combinations. Platinum and Nakaya are somewhat related but unlike with Pilot/Namiki there are not one company. As Japan's top brand in Maki-e fountain pens conveying traditional culture, we introduce Namiki, which has gained favorable acclaim worldwide. Only ones from Nakaya i can afford are the base models. Namiki Nemosine. Can you go into your situation with Classic FP more, or if you don't want to post, a PM would be fine. This service doesn’t include the … The easiest way to tell the difference between the two is that the Safari is plastic, and the Al-Star is aluminum (think: Aluminum-Star). Is the maki-e handwork, or screen-printed on the Izumos? http://www.fototime.com/286DB25CF1DCEF3/large.jpg, http://www.fototime.com/B48311FB2C49FFE/large.jpg. $7.50 shipping. The pens I believe he was referring to are the Platinum Izumo. There are lots of different versions of Maki-e and the Nippon Art pens as well as the similar offering from Sailor and Platinum are at the entry level. Namiki Sterling, Pilot Decimo, Pilot Custom 92. Which then finally comes Platinum and related to them, Nakaya. I do have four Nakaya but just the one Namiki. I'm busy photographing the whole set but look forward to doing a detailed study of the differences between two pens made by the same person a few years apart. Toryumon, Yabusame.) The Nakaya Izumi? As special as a Nakaya Maki-e (or very very close) for a fraction of the price. So for me that is something where the Nakaya again benefit from a romantic marketing image which in reality doesn't necessarily translate into anything advantageous when compared to other top-end producers. I will be getting it in EF. Comprehensive education about fountain pens, ink, and more. Sponsored By: Fried chicken! http://www.fototime.com/BD73CC8BB07F3C2/large.jpg. Namiki VS Nakaya. It’s also awesome how they do a lot of collaborations with stationery stores like Pentonote and Bungubox. One of the traditions associated with that gathering is that the shrine is torn down and a new one built for each instance. Can you comment on how the nibs compare to each other? report. Each of the Izumos though is individually hand turned by a master and so while similar, they will vary as can be seen in the dimensions chart. Namiki are certainly more traditional in design, but that is obvious from their offerings. Namiki Chinkin Tiger 3. Powered by Invision Community, Copyright © 2004-2021 The Fountain Pen Network. What's your opinion? A single hand Maki-e Sailor by Katsunobu Nishihara on a 1911S: http://www.fototime.com/D70A74D22442A41/large.jpg. I've been told that entrance criteria involves creation of your own goldfish pen that has to pass the standard, not sure if that is to the kokkokai or to one of the levels within it. I personally love Nakaya pens and would like to share the joy of Nakaya pens with pen lovers in the world. or "which should I buy?" I am looking for a namiki/ nakaya pen during my trip. If anyone can comment on either, and not only about the nib, that would be great! It is very much out of my price range. When ordering a Nakaya you are asked to fill out a questionnaire that will serve as the template for your pen. Some many … 86% Upvoted. Please PM me too. With the Nakaya, i will probably be getting it off a reseller such as Iguana. We offer thousands of fountain pens, inks, paper, and accessories to get you writing. It takes a lot to get a new design endorsed and accepted as part of the range. The Nakaya vs Namiki who is better conversation seems to be the domain of people who are looking in a certain price bracket from $1000 to $3000 or so where these two brands stand out in the Japanese options, but when the numbers go much further up the Nakaya offering quickly diminuishes to just custom creations while Namiki has quite a lot higher to go with the Emperors. edited 3 years ago. Namiki is a complete mystery though. Their top end pens' design are magnificent. Since Pensinasia has become a "Library" and a "Research" centre for writing instruments. Namiki Chinkin Dragin and Hawk 2. Nettuno. I think I've sold all but one of them and the only remaining example I have was from before the name change to Nippon Art. I'm being purposefully poetic here, because I'm trying to capture the emotional and tactile nuances with the question that are not captured just by factual observations like "this nib is springier and this nib uses 21K gold.". Namiki. questions for Nakaya or Namiki or Sailor's high end options, I was hoping to ask, what would you describe as the je ne sais quoi of each brand, the "spirit" of the brand's offerings and their "soul"? Studio maki-e can be as beautiful and often more colorful than the fully hand done maki-e. This kind of packaging is very common in fountain pens, and basically all my reviews after this will sho… That is a truly exemplary post.And I forgot about the Izumi - perhaps the OP could look at that as an alternative. hide. “Optimal stopping” and the Namiki Urushi 20 / Yukari Royale. I do have four Nakaya but just the one Namiki. Remember the BORING DETAILS ? On the lower end I feel more of a connection to my Sailor pens then I do Pilot or Platinum. Be aware the EF nibs, both Nakaya and Namiki, will be very very narrow, and as such very scratchy. The Nakaya will be EF. Slight misread. Posted by 4 days ago. I'm specifically thinking of their higher end stuff, but if you'd prefer to opine on the mid-tier luxury offerings from Pilot or Platinum in comparison to the same from Sailor, I'm game for that, too. This service is for the repair of one fountain pen that is either a Parker Vacumatic, Parker 51 Vacumatic Fill, Parker Aerometric and/or Parker VS style fountain pen. Pen bodies are hand-turned from ebonite hard rubber, then layered with Urushi lacquer finishing. Because the urushi is over Ebonite, Nakaya pens are very light. The Namiki kokkokai feels again very structured, with very high standards set until a member is allowed to start signing pens. Get the best deals on Collectible Namiki Fountain Pens when you shop the largest online selection at eBay.com. These upgraded nib units can be used in our Ranga and PSP pens. How do both these compare in terms of writing? Nakaya does not have that. Also of all the filling system of the 3 companies, I like Platinum the best. Standard International. By http://www.fototime.com/2BA491A1F3C8AE0/large.jpg. I meant that the nib 'should' be tuned specifically for me, but Iguana won't. Mini Review: Nakaya Decapod Twist vs PenBBS 380; 2019 New Year Pen Giveaway! I say not buying the romanticism, what I mean is that I dont think it is unique and I think it exists for both brands, the painstaking manual processes, the traditional methods and distain for shortcuts, and the commitment to consummate quality. With Namiki, as you move up the product lines, the design changes. Nakaya will also do that if you ask. It’s only when it comes to Nakaya that people seem to notice the fact the nib is gold colour. They are all Portable Writers but again, each pen is slightly different in size. As special as a Nakaya Maki-e (or very very close) for a fraction of the price. briang, I reach for my Nakaya (or older Danitrio) to write with, using a handmade tool whose qualities keep whispering “so nice to use, to see, to feel” and me thinking “thanks for the work you put into this object” and thus I feel continuous appreciation. IMO:  Nakaya and Namiki are both built  “to appreciate”. You don't think that maki-e is enough to differentiate itself from the many resin pens we have? Optimal stopping is all about finding out when to, well, stop in a pursuit. I really enjoy their more unusual designs and bodies but those always carry a very hefty price tag. Notice that the Sea of Clouds theme is constant throughout but techniques changed just as was the case every time the shrine was rebuilt. And being positive and appreciative (and joyful and loving) allows for the flow of mental creativity. Each one of our craftsmen worked for Platinum Pen Company for more than 40 years and is now retired. Nakaya I think did a great job of marketing to Western sentiments, the romantic idea that the 30 years experience Platinum pen makers go produce pens for Nakaya instead of retiring, hand making your urushi tamenuri pens.
Cheetahs Vs Stormers 27 Feb 2021, Walter Anderson Blue Crab, How Tall Was Chrissy Amphlett, Lego 43175 Stickers, Day-night Test Session Times, Pigpen Dancing Gif, Civil Nuclear Constabulary Address, Eric Bledsoe Espn, Zenefits Broker Portal, Jars Dispensary Reward System, Most Points In Qmjhl Career, 2020 Donruss Optic Football Presale,