Joe Cinque's Consolation is a film that isn't afraid to ask difficult questions about the line between good and evil, the nature of mental illness and the failings of community. “Joe Cinque is dead” is the mantra guiding Garner and her reader through her book. Lots of people knew about Anu’s intention to kill Joe and her alleged intention of killing herself. Refresh and try again. But I couldn't get past the author's need to consistently insert herself into the story. She gives her own perspective on everything. Bookmark File PDF True Fiction Ian Ludlow Thrillers Book 1 ... enigmatic Joe Pike, are hip-deep in a deadly situation as they plummet into a world of South Central gangs, corrupt cops, and conspiracies of silence. Of Anu’s actions: ‘What is ‘simple wickedness’? Was greeted as I came through the…, Chris Uhlmann should receive an award for his writing about Twitter. You might think true crime is an unusual genre for book club reading, but I’m glad my book club chose Joe Cinque’s Consolation (2004). Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Joe Cinque's Consolation at Amazon.com. Why did no one warn Joe? This should be a book about Joe Cinque and his family, but it's really about Helen Garner and her reaction to the case. There are things that an investigation could look at. Haunting. Author: Helen Garner. She planned it well in advance, talked about what she was going to do (kill Joe)to friends and went to great lengths to obtain the materials she needed and practiced how to use the syringe with which she injected him with heroin after drugging him with rohypnol. The Aged Care Royal Commission had laid down its findings. Why did no one call an ambulance earlier when he might have been saved? The trauma of the family of a murder victim is rarely mentioned in a d. An excellent and powerful book and one of those stories that remind you how money, influence and the passing of time leave victims of violent crimes, in this case murder, lost in the outpouring of sympathy not for the victim but for the perpetrator. I have seen this happen in other true crime books. Joe Cinque’s Consolation(M), national release from Thursday. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. 5 stars for readability and the story itself and the concept of looking at the impact of the justice system on victim's families, but NO STARS EVER for incredibly annoying whingey intrusions of garner on the narrative and her lack of impartiality and failure to conduct any research into how criminal sentencing actually works or even *should* work. She seeks knowledge of Joe from family and friends; there is no other way of knowing him. GENRE. Helen Garner was born in Geelong in 1942. An article in The New Yorker about Helen Garner prompted me to look for her books on kindle. Unfortunately, the victim Joe Cinque (pronounced‘chin-kway’) did not live to graduate from Miss Experience’s School of Hard Knocks, having been rendered helpless by Rohypnol and killed with an injection of heroin administered by his fiancée Anu Singh that she’d procured with the assistance of her BF Madhavi Rao, both Law students @ Australian National University. Like Joe Cinque’s Consolation, this is another book written by an individual unhappy with a criminal sentence.However, Aussie mum Mel Jacob approaches the topic from the opposite angle. And a lot of anger and frustration. UHHHHHHH i kind of hated this. After seeing the film, I knew I had to read the book. The was what drew me to the story, something like Donna Tartt’s The Secret History as a real life tragedy. This is a complex, confusing and heartbreaking look at a crime that should never have happened - simply because there were people who knew it was going to, and did nothing about it. An outstanding emotional gauge to the murder of Joe Cinque, and a fitting elegy for a man almost forgotten in the legal debacle which followed. This should be a book about Joe Cinque and his family, but it's really about Helen Garner and her reaction to the case. Book Review: Joe Cinque’s Consolation, by Helen Garner. GRIEF AND THE LAW JOE CINQUE'S CONSOLATION by Helen Garner By Geoff Coates W ... Eva Scheerlinck, asked me to review this book, she said that she hadn’t read Helen Garner since her university days. But I couldn't get past the author's need to consistently insert herself into the story. I really want to read this book by the way. (Continentals tend to think the law represents what ideally ought to occur, whilst in the English-speaking world we think it’s what we have to do in real life - which is why we actually pay our income taxes every year tho’ nobody in Greece would ever think of doing anything so idiotic!). Profoundly troubling but compelling tale, and clearly Garner is a very good writer. The further away in days, months and years that a defendant moves from the sight of the crime the more they are viewed as innocent or at the very least justified in their actions. This should be a book about Joe Cinque and his family, but it's really about Helen Garner and her reaction to the case. And in the midst of it all, but forgotten, Joe Cinque. To this day Anu Singh shows no remorse for her crime but paints herself as the victim. “Invisible magpies warbled in the plane trees. At one point the author says that men cannot manage high-maintenance friendships; @ least in my own case I’d like to think she’s wrong, tho I’ll grant we males usually have a steeper learning curve. I am still, like the author and Joe's family, left with questions. Booktopia has Joe Cinque's Consolation, A True Story of Death, Grief and the Law by Helen Garner. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Joe Cinque's Consolation: Film Tie-In at Amazon.com.